Why 79% of Your Employees Are Still Not Engaged — And What Finally Changes That?
By Seni Penitani | Founder, Community Leadership Builders | Culture Transformer | Transformational Leadership Developer
Employee engagement is a challenge to America — and to the world.
After all these years of HR training, leadership seminars, compliance programs, and well-intentioned initiatives, we still cannot move the number. Gallup reports that globally, only 21% of employees are genuinely engaged at work. In the United States — the highest-performing region in the world — it is still only 33%. And in 2024, for only the second time in twelve years, the global engagement rate actually went down.
We have to stop and ask the honest question: What is going on?
Organizations are not ignoring the problem. They are investing in it. Training budgets are growing. HR departments are expanding. Leadership programs are multiplying. And yet the needle barely moves.
The problem is not that organizations are doing nothing. The problem is that they are doing the wrong thing — or more precisely, they are doing the right things insufficiently, while leaving the most important thing untouched.
Transactional training is not bad. Compliance training is necessary. Skills development matters. But after decades of evidence, we have to be honest: compliance and skills training alone produce a 21% global engagement rate. They develop the worker. They never touch the person. And you cannot build a flourishing organization on a transactional foundation.
Gallup recently asked thousands of employees one direct question: "What is missing from your current work experience that would make you feel more connected to your employer?" The responses fell into four clear themes.
As a Culture Transformer and Transformational Leadership Developer, I want to walk through each one — and show you exactly how the 7C Transformational Leadership Model™ was built to address every single one of them from the inside out.
---
CAUSE #1 — ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
📊 Gallup Finding: 32% of employees describe their workplace as isolated or impersonal — rising to 44% among Gen Z workers and 41% among remote employees.
(Source: Gallup State of the Global Workplace 2024)
Nearly one in three employees feels isolated at work. For Gen Z — the generation now entering the workforce in the greatest numbers — that number is nearly one in two. This is not a minor inconvenience. Isolation at work is a culture failure. And culture does not fix itself. It has to be intentionally designed.
Here is what I know from twelve years working inside a juvenile correctional facility — one of the most high-stress, high-isolation work environments that exists: a toxic or impersonal culture will undo every good thing you try to build. I watched brilliant behavioral programs get dismantled the moment young men returned to environments that did not reinforce what they had learned. The training was not the problem. The culture was.
Peter Drucker was right — culture eats strategy for lunch. But most organizations still treat culture as a values poster on the wall. The 7C Model treats it as a living system that must be diagnosed, designed, and developed with the same intentionality as any business strategy.
HOW THE 7C MODEL ADDRESSES THIS:
C5 — Culture is dedicated entirely to this challenge. We identify where your organization sits on the culture spectrum — from Complacency to Compliance to a Courageous and Transformed Culture — and build the systems, shared routines, and accountability structures that make connection the default, not the exception.
C6 — Community goes even deeper, moving beyond team-building into a strength-based community where people value relationships as much as results. Connection does not happen by accident. We build it on purpose — through intentional design, frequent feedback, and clarity about how every individual role fits into the larger mission.
---
CAUSE #2 — LEADERSHIP TRANSPARENCY
📊 Gallup Finding: 29% of employees say they lack clear, honest, or consistent communication from leaders — especially during times of organizational change.
(Source: Gallup State of the Global Workplace 2024)
Nearly three in ten employees do not trust the communication coming from their leaders. They want honesty. They want to understand the reasoning behind decisions. They want space to contribute — not just to receive information after the fact. And in times of change, ambiguity from leadership is one of the fastest ways to destroy trust that took years to build.
This is a courage problem as much as it is a communication problem. Most leaders do not lack the desire to be transparent. They lack the courage to face difficult realities, name them clearly, and lead their people through them with honesty. Transparency requires courage. And courage — I have learned from years in the hardest rooms — is not a personality trait you either have or you don't. It is a learned skill that can be trained.
Gallup confirms what Scripture has always taught — followers need four things from their leaders: Hope, Trust, Compassion, and Stability. Every one of those four is eroded when a leader communicates with ambiguity, avoids hard conversations, or leads from fear rather than conviction.
HOW THE 7C MODEL ADDRESSES THIS:
C2 — Courage trains leaders to face reality with clarity — developing physical, moral, and psychological courage as practical, learnable skills. This is not motivational content. It is structured courage training applied to real leadership challenges.
C3 — Compassion ensures that courageous communication is delivered with genuine care for people — because transparency without compassion is just harshness. Together, Courage and Compassion produce the kind of leader employees actually trust. Not because they are perfect — but because they are honest, present, and genuinely committed to their people.
---
CAUSE #3 — RESOURCE INVESTMENT
📊 Gallup Finding: 25% of employees say their organizations underinvest in people — pay, tools, staffing, and development. They see it as a signal of how much the organization values their work.
(Source: Gallup State of the Global Workplace 2024)
A quarter of your workforce is watching how you invest — and drawing conclusions about whether they matter. Fair compensation, functional tools, and sustainable workloads are not extras. They are baseline conditions for engagement. But I want to push this conversation beyond pay and tools.
The deepest resource investment an organization can make is in the development of the whole person. When an organization invests only in skills training and compliance programs, it sends a clear message: we see you as a resource, not a person. Employees feel that message even when no one says it out loud. And they respond with exactly the level of engagement you would expect — minimal.
The organizations winning on engagement — those Gallup identifies as best-practice companies with up to 70% engagement rates — are the ones investing in their people's strengths. Gallup's CliftonStrengths® research shows that teams focused on strengths development see:
• 23% higher employee engagement
• 18% increased performance
• 73% lower attrition
• 29% more likely to stay with the company next year
• 42% more likely to stay for their entire career
That is not a soft return on investment. That is a business case.
HOW THE 7C MODEL ADDRESSES THIS:
C1 — Calling is the deepest investment an organization can make in a person. Using DISC Behavioral Profiles and Gallup CliftonStrengths® assessments, we help every employee discover their individual calling — the intersection of their strengths, talents, and purpose — and connect it to the organization's mission.
When people see their work as part of their calling rather than separate from it, the entire equation changes. They are no longer resources being managed. They are people being developed. And people who are genuinely developed give everything they have.
---
CAUSE #4 — PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
📊 Gallup Finding: 14% of employees cite a lack of ongoing feedback, recognition, and development opportunities as a key driver of disconnection from their employer.
(Source: Gallup State of the Global Workplace 2024)
Annual or biannual reviews cannot replace the ongoing, individualized feedback employees need to grow. Fourteen percent may seem like the smallest number in this list — but do not underestimate it. The absence of meaningful feedback is not just a management problem. It is a transformation problem. People cannot grow without honest feedback, consistent accountability, and someone who believes in their potential enough to hold them to it.
This is the lesson I carried out of twelve years in juvenile corrections. The young men I worked with did not lack talent. They lacked someone who would sit with them consistently, hold them accountable with compassion, and refuse to let them settle for less than their potential. That is not an annual review. That is a coaching relationship.
"Information alone has never transformed anyone. The missing ingredient is always the same — a coaching relationship built on accountability, honest feedback, and real-world application. That is the bridge between what people learn and who they become."
HOW THE 7C MODEL ADDRESSES THIS:
C4 — Coaching Growth is the engine of the entire 7C Model. It is the bridge between information and transformation. CLB is built around small group coaching of no more than 10 to 12 people — not one-on-one isolation.
Why small groups? Because there are things a leader will never say to their coach alone that they will say to a trusted peer walking the same journey beside them. That peer accountability, that honest feedback loop, that shared community of practice — that is where lasting behavior change happens. Not in a workshop. Not in an annual review. In a coaching relationship sustained over time.
Individualism in leadership is dangerous. The Jesus Model, the Wesley Model, and the Cru Model all confirm what research now proves: we grow faster, go further, and hold gains longer in community than we ever do alone.
---
THE ANSWER IS NOT MORE TRAINING. IT IS A DIFFERENT KIND OF TRAINING.
Let me be clear about something. Transactional training is not the enemy. Compliance matters. Skills matter. Every organization needs both. But after decades of evidence, we have to be honest: compliance and skills training alone have given us a 21% global engagement rate. That is the ceiling of the transactional approach.
What happens when we add Transformational Training alongside the Transactional? What happens when we stop treating engagement as a HR metric to be managed and start treating it as a human outcome to be developed?
Gallup has already shown us the answer. There are companies today with 70% engagement rates. They are not anomalies. They are proof of concept — organizations that invested in strengths, built courageous cultures, and developed leaders who lead with both courage and compassion. The success is not random. It is reproducible. It just needs a framework.
That framework is the 7C Transformational Leadership Model™.
THE SEVEN CS:
C1 — Calling: Every employee discovers their unique purpose and connects it to the organization's mission
C2 — Courage: Leaders train courage as a learnable skill — facing reality, speaking truth, and leading through fear
C3 — Compassion: Building the trust and psychological safety that makes everything else possible
C4 — Coaching Growth: The engine — small group coaching that bridges information and lasting transformation
C5 — Culture: Moving organizations from Complacency to Compliance to a Courageous, Transformed Culture
C6 — Community: Building strength-based communities where people grow together and take that growth home
C7 — Commitment to a Cause: Developing people who do not just show up — they give themselves to something worth their best
My goal as a Culture Transformer and Transformational Leadership Developer is not simply to improve your engagement score. It is to ensure your organization grows holistically — that individuals discover their calling, that leaders develop the courage and compassion to lead with integrity, that coaching replaces managing as the primary development approach, that your culture is intentionally designed rather than accidentally formed, and that your people build the kind of community that spills beyond the office walls into the homes and neighborhoods they call home.
Because here is what I know from personal experience as an immigrant who spent twelve years in one of the hardest environments imaginable: the right organizational culture can be the best thing that ever happens to a person. Those twelve years grew me in ways I never grew before — because the principles I was developing were not just professional tools. They were a way of life.
Your organization can do that for your people. You can be the best thing that ever happened to them. Not because you pay them more or give them better perks — but because you develop them, believe in them, and give them something worth committing to.
We are not just turning disengaged employees into engaged ones. We are turning organizations into movements — where people do not just show up for a paycheck, but give themselves to a cause worthy of their best.
The trajectory of the workplace does not have to keep going south. But it will not change with more of the same. It will change when organizations make the bold, intentional decision to move from transactional to transformational.
That decision starts here.
---
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Seni Penitani is the Founder of Community Leadership Builders and the creator of the 7C Transformational Leadership Model™. He is a Culture Transformer, Transformational Leadership Developer, Gallup CliftonStrengths® Certified Coach, Maxwell Leadership Certified Coach, DISC Behavioral Consultant, ATD Certified Facilitator, and Human Flourishing Trained Coach. His model is in alignment with research from Harvard's Human Flourishing Program and grounded by insights from Gallup research. He has 25 years of frontline leadership experience including 12 years inside a juvenile correctional facility and 13 years coaching college students and young professionals with Cru.
🌐 www.communityleadershipbuilders.com
📞 Book a Free Discovery Call at www.communityleadershipbuilders.com/contact